Joel Greenblatt fit · Magic Formula - high ROIC + cheap EV/EBIT
Is Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) a Joel Greenblatt Stock?
Low Magic Formula score - expensive, low ROIC, or both.
22/100
FNot a fit
3/5 criteria passed
+2 sector-quality lift. Top-quintile within its sector on 1 of 5 quality metrics. Raw pillar score 20 → lifted to 22 before grade derivation.
Joel Greenblatt's Criteria, Applied to SIGI
EBIT/EV yield ≥ 10%
key9.9%
ROIC ≥ 25%
key3.4%
EV/EBIT ≤ 12
10.1x
Gross margin ≥ 30%
40.6%
Earnings yield ≥ 6%
8.9%
How SIGI Scores on Other Strategies
Live Financial Snapshot
Market cap
$5.16B
P/E (TTM)
11.3x
ROIC (TTM)
3.39%
Gross margin
40.6%
Other Joel Greenblatt fit reports
Frequently Asked Questions
What is SIGI's Joel Greenblatt fit score?
SIGI scores 22/100 on our Joel Greenblatt fit engine - grade F. Low Magic Formula score - expensive, low ROIC, or both.
Does Joel Greenblatt actually own SIGI?
Our score is computed from financial fundamentals against Joel Greenblatt's published criteria. We don't claim that Joel Greenblatt personally owns or recommends SIGI.
How often is this score updated?
SIGI's Joel Greenblatt fit score is recomputed daily from the latest TTM financials. The page below shows when it was last refreshed.
Key terms in this analysis
Educational tool, not investment advice. Scores are computed from publicly-available financial data against published investing-strategy criteria. We do not claim that Joel Greenblatt personally owns or recommends SIGI.